In the finale episode of the first season, things take a terrible turn on prom night when a car accident happens. After Annie (Anneliese Judge) ditches Kyle (Logan Allen) on prom night, he spends the night with Nellie (Simone Lockhart), Jackson’s (Sam Ashby) sister. However, they are interrupted when Jackson and his friends Tyler (Carson Rowland), CeCe (Harlan Drum), and Annie come back to the house for an after-party. A fight erupts, and Kyle storms out of the house.
The scene then cuts to Maddie (JoAnna Garcia Swisher) and Bill (Chris Klein), where he pleads her to take him back. Dana Sue (Brooke Elliott) talks with Isaac (Chris Medlin) about the possibility of his parentage, and Helen (Heather Headley) spends some quality time with Erik (Dion Johnstone). While all of this is going on, they get a phone call about a car accident.
They are worried about Tyler, believing that he had been driving the car. However, on arriving at the scene, they find out that it was Kyle behind the wheel. The cops mention another person was in the car as well, but their identity is not clarified. So, who was in the car with Kyle?